Tuesday, February 6, 2007

My Israel Question

Australian journalist's new book takes heat for posing "My Israel Question"
Amal Awad, The Electronic Intifada, 27 September 2006

Sydney-based journalist and author Antony Loewenstein is used to controversy. On many occasions he has told of how his critical assessment of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict as a Jew has left him a pariah in family and social circles. This is unlikely to change anytime soon given that he spent the last couple of years penning the newly released My Israel Question, a self-critical consideration of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict in a particularly Australian context.

Loewenstein comes from "a liberal Jewish family" with parents he describes as once having been "unthinking Zionists", who he later realised were simply uninformed because of their reliance on Jewish and mainstream press for their understanding of the conflict. Eventually, despite being deeply moved by his heritage, Loewenstein realised his own discomfort with "the default Jewish attitude towards Israel". His own revulsion at what happened to Jews in Auschwitz changed him, he says. "Seeing the results of blind hatred and unchallenged devotion slowly led me to be more questioning on a range of matters, including my heritage and the state of Israel."

This led Loewenstein to the realisation that "The morality... of Israeli actions was never questioned". Zionism portrayed Jews as blameless victims, yet Loewenstein was struggling with the disregard for Palestinians. Where was the platform for criticism of Israel? He could not unquestioningly support a Jewish state following his "self-education on the plight of the Palestinian people and the ongoing efforts of the Zionist enterprise to deprive them of a homeland".

So the essence of his assessment is simply this: "How could a democratic state maintain a brutal occupation over another people for nearly 40 years?"

Australian journalist Peter Manning said on Australian radio recently that "The Palestinian narrative barely gets oxygen in the Australian media." That his assessment could be easily applied globally is disheartening, but the truth of the statement is undeniable. This is a driving element in Loewenstein's discussion.

The unbalanced media coverage of the recent Israeli attacks in Gaza and Lebanon in particular certainly supports this. There is little genuine and fair debate about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As Loewenstein wrote in Znet in September, following release of his book, debate is "invariably overly emotive, factually challenged, partisan and counter-productive".

Early in his book, Loewenstein acknowledges Israel as a state and its right to existence. However, he is concerned with Zionism and its part in the never-ending conflict. Loewenstein is not explicit as to whether having an Israeli state can be divorced from Zionism, and this is a major flaw in his analysis. However, his sentiment is clear: "There must be a way for Israel to exist securely while allowing justice for the Palestinian people".

In general, Loewenstein's treatise is not flawless. There is certainly scope for deeper discussion and analysis. But in his fluid style, he covers a fair amount of subject matter, dedicating pages and pages to the news media and pro-Israel lobby, highlighting what he views as controlling political Zionism and the resulting accusation that criticism of Israel is equivalent to anti-Semitism. Loewenstein offers compelling analysis and evidence as to why the Palestinians are consistently being overlooked in this conflict - from Sunday school teachings in which "inconvenient facts were whitewashed", the inability to separate opposition to Zionism from anti-Semitism in the general discussion, as well as the power of the pro-Israel lobby within the media.

He covers US politics, but dissects the Australian discourse as well, beginning with a highly detailed report on the Sydney Peace Prize awarded to Hanan Ashrawi in 2003, an accolade that was marred by uproar and objections particularly from the pro-Israel lobby.

Such chapters are the high points in the book, as Loewenstein has exposed tactics used by the Australian pro-Israel lobby. This is particularly significant as these are points on which the media have taken notice and will continue to do so.

He argues that the Jewish lobby is responsible for the media's inability to allow the Palestinians a voice, and consequently the media itself plays its own significant role in the conflict and avoids the issue in general. Loewenstein considers the presence of foreign journalists within Israel and the lack in West Bank, citing Haaretz's Amira Hass who lives in Ramallah as an exception.

A 2004 report from Reporters without Borders cited harassment of journalists by Palestinian militants as a reason why journalists avoid the West Bank and Gaza, yet the low ranking in terms of press freedom is accountable to 'acts of violence against the press by the Israeli army' not Palestinians. Some may argue that Palestinians are in part culpable for their lack of power in the media, but arguably, Israel is more adept in the media arena, strategic in its approach even at military level.

This is an important book, and it comes at a crucial time. With the spectre of Lebanon's destruction faded from mainstream media, it's easy to forget that there are many still living and breathing the conflict and its effects. Israelis and Palestinians both understand this well, and Loewenstein does not pretend that there isn't suffering among the Israelis.

Rather, he critically considers the issue in order to understand himself how the Israelis' right to live in peace and security exists at the expense of Palestinians, people whose voice is barely heard outside of independent media. He declares his intention to show the Palestinian side of the occupation, demonstrating the need to escape from Zionist perspectives that shed no light on the injustices Palestinians are consistently subjected to. And this much is clear throughout. He has, since the publication of his book, pointed out that he was unable to offer divergent views from Jewish leaders because they refused to participate.

Yet perhaps a misstep on Loewenstein's part is that, for all his intentions to breathe life into the Palestinian narrative, he does not acknowledge the work of Palestinian and Arab activists in Australia. In fact, what is truly missing from this book is a true Palestinian 'voice'. The general sentiment of activists in Australia is certainly that his book is weaker for it. Indeed, it is a missed opportunity.

Critics have been thus far quite scathing, primarily attacking the legitimacy of Loewenstein's claims, and arguing a lack of balance in his evaluation of the conflict. It has even been called simplistic as well as superficial in its take on the situation. However, it is Loewenstein's lean towards the Palestinian narrative that seems to offend the most and to many reduces the book to having little, if any, worth.

This is far from true. Whether there are minor errors in Loewenstein's extensive research, and certainly there is room for deeper exploration, the analysis itself is effectively and passionately presented. And this is what it seems to be - minor errors that do not undermine the legitimacy of Loewenstein's book. For example, much has been made of him sharing the contents of private conversations he had with family members, the Greens, who he stayed with when he went to Israel to research his book, yet only two pages are dedicated to them.

That the criticism has overshadowed any thoughtful analysis of the content and message of the book is instructive: commentators indeed struggle to be heard when presenting views other than the dominant Israeli apologist side of the conflict, views that seek to humanise Palestinians.

The reaction essentially illustrates Loewenstein's own argument that reasonable debate is impossible. Indeed, it seems that any assessment that closely examines the effects on Palestinians is immediately going to be discounted as a credible source of information as very few have considered the importance of this kind of narrative. He is given little or no credit for his stance.

Perhaps Loewenstein's consideration is remarkable enough for the fact that he is Jewish and consequently fighting the conflict on a deeply personal level. He could certainly dig deeper, and his approach shows a desire to learn more. Still, his thoughtful analysis makes the book readable and affecting. This is a candid study of a conflict that only grows more heated as time passes.

My Israel Question is essential reading that will provoke thought and most importantly, investigation. Hopefully, readers unused to measured consideration will look deeper into the raging conflict because, as Lowenstein writes, "It's time for a radical rethinking of the conflict".

Amal Awad is an editor based in Sydney, Australia and an editorial assistant for The Electronic Intifada.


• Opinion/Editorial
• Diaries
• Human Rights
• Development
• Israel Lobby Watch
• Internet & Tech
• Business & Economy

• Role of the Media
• Coverage Trends
• Journalists in Danger
• EI in the Press

• Activism News
• Action Items
• Letters to the Media

• BY TOPIC directory
• Arts, Music & Culture
• Satire from BNN
• Multimedia
• Letters to EI
• EI Shop
• EI Bookstore

• Weekday Press Picks
• Wire Service Photos
• Casualty Stats

Review: Iraq in Fragments
30 January 2007

Comedians & Writers raise in San Francisco raise money for Slain Iraqi Comedian Walid Hassan
9 January 2007

Singing "the devil's music" will get you killed
23 November 2006

Headlines powered by eIraq

This webpage uses Javascript to display some content.
Please enable Javascript in your browser and reload this page.

E-mail this Page Print this Page Top of Page Art, Music & Culture Index


The Electronic Intifada needs your ongoing help to offer information about the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict.

©2000-2006 electronicIntifada.net


Book Reviews and Author Interviews

The Electronic Intifada has reviewed books that pertain a wide range of themes relating to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and Palestinian culture. The following is a listing of book reviews, interviews with authors, and book exceprts published by EI, organized by book author name.

Purchase One Country on Amazon.com
• One Country: A Bold Proposal to End the Israeli-Palestinian Impasse
Special coverage
Recent articles by Ali Abunimah

• Is There An Islamic Problem?
Making sense of our times: Exceprts from "Is There an Islamic Problem?" (14 October 2004)

• Sharon and my Mother-in-Law
Reviewed by Maureen Clare Murphy (6 March 2005)

• Broken Bridge
Reviewed by Fouad Moughrabi (5 February 2007)

Purchase The Second Palestinian Intifada on Amazon.com
• The Second Palestinian Intifada: A Chronicle of a People's Struggle
Reviwed by Remi Kanazi (31 October 2006)

• Culture and Resistance: Conversations with Edward W. Said
Reviewed by Maureen Clare Murphy (9 January 2004)

• Resistance: My Life for Lebanon
Reviewed by Maureen Clare Murphy (18 December 2003)

• Palestine Peace Not Apartheid

Purchase Blood and Religion on Amazon.com
Special coverage

• Against All Enemies
Reviewed by Maureen Clare Murphy (29 March 2004)

• Blood and Religion: The Unmasking of the Jewish and Democratic State
Reviewed by Raymond Deane (12 June 2006)
Recent articles by Jonathan Cook

• The Case for Israel
Reviewed by Feroze Sidhwa (15 June 2005)
Analyzed by Regan Boychuk (18 April 2005)

• Three Wishes: Palestinian and Israeli Children Speak
Reviewed by Fouad Moughrabi (5 February 2007)

Purchase Live from Palestine on Amazon.com
EL FASSED, ARJAN (contributor)
• Live from Palestine: International and Palestinian Direct Action Against the Israeli Occupation
Excerpt: Live from Palestine: The Diaries Project (1 December 2003)
Recent articles by Arjan El Fassed

• Beyond Chutzpah: On the misuse of anti-Semitism and the abuse of history
Interviewed by Christopher Brown (25 May 2006)

• "Beyond Words"
Quicktime Video (12 June 2004)
• "A Prayer Band" (13 September 2005)
• ZaatarDiva

Purchase The Gun and the Olive Branch on Amazon.com

Interviewed by Christopher Brown (8 June 2006)

• Reporting from Ramallah: An Israeli Journalist in an Occupied Land
Reviewed by Tina Dybvik (11 December 2003)

• The Gun and the Olive Branch: The Roots of Violence in the Middle East
Interviewed by Maureen Clare Murphy (9 January 2004)

• Sabra and Shatila 1982

Purchase Aid, Diplomacy, And Facts On The Ground on Amazon.com
Reviewed by Victor Kattan (21 May 2005)

• The Woman I Left Behind
Reviwed by Maureen Clare Murphy (10 April 2006)

• Aid, Diplomacy, and Facts on the Ground: The Case of Palestine
Reviewed by Stuart Reigeluth (10 November 2005)

• Gaza Blues: Different Stories
Reviewed by Amal Awad (7 March 2006)

Purchase A Little Piece of Ground on Amazon.com

• The Attack: A Novel
Reviewed by Amal Awad (18 December 2006)

• The Iron Cage: The Story of the Palestinian Struggle for Statehood by Rashid Khalidi
Reviewed by The Economist (25 November 2006)

• Thy Kingdome Come: Pocket Guide to the Holy Land
Reviewed by Mulham Assir (24 November 2006)

Purchase Tell Me Lies on Amazon.com
• A Little Piece of Ground
Reviewed by Fouad Moughrabi (5 February 2007)
Reviewed by Ron Jacobs (22 January 2007)

• What Went Wrong: Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response
Reviewed by Juan Cole (27 January 2003)

LLEWELLYN, TIM (contributor)
• Tell me lies: Propaganda and Media Distortion in the Attack on Iraq
Excerpt: Why the BBC Ducks the Palestinian Story (6 February 2004)

Purchase The Persistene of the Palestinian Question on Amazon.com
• My Israel Question
Reviewed by Amal Awad (27 September 2006)

• The Persistence of the Palestinian Question: Essays on Zionism and the Palestinians
Reviewed by Sally Bland (26 October 2006)
• Pinochet in Palestine, Joseph Massad (11 November 2006)
• The (Anti-) Palestinian Authority, Joseph Massad (18 June 2006)
• Blaming the lobby, Joseph Massad (24 March 2006)
• Munich, or Making Baklava, Joseph Massad (3 February 2006)
• Targeting the university, Joseph Massad (4 June 2005)
• Joseph Massad responds to the intimidation of Columbia University, Joseph Massad (3 November 2004)
• Reducing the Palestinians, Joseph Massad (27 December 2003)
• Edward Said's journey to Ithaka, Joseph Massad (10 October 2003)
• Curriculum reform should start in the U.S. and Israel, Joseph Massad (18 August 2003)
• Policing the academy, Joseph Massad (14 April 2003)
• Post-Oslo solidarity, Joseph Massad (26 February 2003)
• Sartre, European intellectuals and Zionism, Joseph Massad (31 January 2003)

Purchase The Other Side of Israel on Amazon.com

• The Myth of Palestinian Development: Political Aid and Sustainable Deceit
Reviewed by Sam Bahour (16 August 2004)

• The Other Side of Israel: My Journey Across the Jewish/Arab Divide
Interviewed by Savitri Groag (18 December 2005)
Reviewed by Avigail Abarbanel (17 November 2005)

• The Case Against Israel
Reviewed by Raymond Deane (9 May 2006)

• Occupied Voices: Stories of Everyday Life from the Second Intifada
Interviewed by Maureen Clare Murphy (11 February 2004)

Purchase Occupied Voices on Amazon.com
• Bad News from Israel
Interviewed by Palestine Report (21 October 2004)

• Intifada: The Long Day of Rage
Reviewed by Raymond Deane (15 December 2006)

• Bethlehem Besieged: Stories of Hope in Times of Trouble
Reviewed by Arjan El Fassed (19 August 2004)

• Prickly Pears of Palestine

Purchase Bethlehem Besieged on Amazon.com

Excerpt: From the Mouth of the Lion's Den (15 January 2007)

• Peace Under Fire: Israel, Palestine and the International Solidarity Movement
Interviewed by Stefan Christoff (29 July 2004)

• Portraits of Israelis and Palestinians: For My Parents
Reviewed by Maureen Clare Murphy (21 July 2003)

• The One State Solution: A breakthough plan for peace in the Israeli-Palestinian deadlock

Purchase The One-State Solution on Amazon.com

Reviewed by Iqbal Jassat (16 July 2005)
• Taken for a Ride by the Israeli Left, Steven Friedman and Virginia Tilley (26 January 2007)
• The Case for Boycotting Israel, Virginia Tilley (7 August 2006)

WEIR, ALISON (contributor)
• Censored 2005: The Top 25 Censored Stories
Israel and Palestine, Finally: A chapter from CENSORED 2005 (5 October 2005)

• Gaza Blues: Different Stories
Reviewed by Amal Awad (7 March 2006)

Related Links

• BY TOPIC: Books & Literature
• EI Bookstore

Source: Book Review

With a crippled government, and constantly under siege, average Palestinians find themselves in a veritable pressure cooker, squeezed between the pressures of Israel, the international community, and now the largest two Palestinian political parties, Fateh and Hamas.

EI EXCLUSIVE: Leaked Israeli document gives frightening glimpse of apartheid
Ali Abunimah, The Electronic Intifada, 25 January 2007

No comments: